Moon's Cycle Tied to Heart Surgery Outcomes: Study
Patients who got a vessel repair during waning full moon fared better
MONDAY, July 22, 2013 (HealthDay News) -- Scheduled for heart surgery? A new study suggests you might fare better or worse depending on the moon's cycle at the time of the procedure.
Researchers found that patients who had a type of heart surgery called acute aortic dissection repair during a full moon were less likely to die and had shorter hospital stays than if the same operation happened at other points in the lunar cycle.
Aortic dissection is a serious condition in which a tear develops in the aorta, the large artery that carries blood out of the heart for distribution to the rest of the body. The condition made headlines when actor John Ritter died of an aortic dissection in 2003.
Researchers led by Dr. Frank Sellke, co-director of the Cardiovascular Institute at Rhode Island, The Miriam and Newport hospitals, wanted to see whether seasons and lunar cycles phases had any impact on hospital survival and length of stay after patients underwent aortic dissection repair.
"While there has been previous research of seasonal impacts on cardiovascular disease, there has not been any data about the effect of the lunar cycles on cardiac cases, until now," Sellke said in a hospital news release.
According to the study, the odds of dying after an aortic dissection repair was reduced during the full phase of the moon, as was the patient's average length of stay in the hospital, Sellke said.
Patients who had their surgery during a full moon stayed in hospital for 10 days, compared with 14 days for those who had their surgery during two other moon phases, according to the study published online July 22 in the journal Interactive Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery.
The study could only point to an association between the moon's phases and heart surgery outcomes, it could not prove cause and effect. And of course, since aortic dissection occurs randomly, scheduling a repair procedure to match the moon's phase could be tough.
"Can we always plan for such procedures to be performed around lunar cycles? Of course not," Sellke said. "But better understanding the effects of the environment -- including seasonal and lunar cycles -- on our health can help us to better understand these rhythms, and ultimately provide better care for our patients."
Two heart experts agreed that the study results were intriguing.
"The field of 'chronobiology' has previously shown the impact of season (i.e., dissections occur more frequently in the winter months) with dissections, and the impact of the time of day with heart attacks," said Dr. Abe DeAnda, an associate professor in the department of cardiothoracic surgery at NYU Langone Medical Center, in New York City. "And as most surgeons would claim, these emergencies seem to happen at night."
However, he also agreed with Sellke that the findings have little practical applications, because, "unfortunately, you can't schedule your acute dissection nor the repair."
Dr. David Friedman is chief of heart failure services at North Shore-LIJ's Plainview Hospital, in Plainview, N.Y. He called the findings "tantalizing" and agreed with DeAnda that other studies have shown associations between periods of time -- the winter, for example, or Monday mornings -- and an increased odds for heart attacks and strokes.
But he said the jury is still out on the effects of the moon's cycle on aortic repairs.
"Although the findings showed decreased chance of death and shorter hospital stays of those patients who had aortic dissection repair during a full-moon period, I don't think enough data is yet available to draw any meaningful generalizations," Friedman said.
The MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia has more about aortic dissection.