Written by Steven Reinberg
Updated on August 19, 2004
HealthDay operates under the strictest editorial standards. Our syndicated news content is completely independent of any financial interests, is based solely on industry-respected sources and the latest scientific research, and is carefully fact-checked by a team of industry experts to ensure accuracy.
- All articles are edited and checked for factual accuracy by our Editorial Team prior to being published.
- Unless otherwise noted, all articles focusing on new research are based on studies published in peer-reviewed journals or issued from independent and respected medical associations, academic groups and governmental organizations.
- Each article includes a link or reference to the original source.
- Any known potential conflicts of interest associated with a study or source are made clear to the reader.
Please see our Editorial and Fact-Checking Policy for more detail.Editorial and Fact-Checking Policy
HealthDay Editorial Commitment
HeathDay is committed to maintaining the highest possible levels of impartial editorial standards in the content that we present on our website. All of our articles are chosen independent of any financial interests. Editors and writers make all efforts to clarify any financial ties behind the studies on which we report.
FRIDAY, Aug. 20, 2004 (HealthDayNews) -- Having your tonsils removed is a relatively simple operation but complications can occur, and a new British study suggests that newer so-called "hot" surgical techniques triple the risk of postoperative bleeding.
Such techniques have only become more common in the past decade or two, the researchers noted, supplanting what is known as a "cold steel" surgery, which was standard practice for almost 100 years.
The ability to control bleeding during surgery, particularly with young children, has made "hot" surgery an attractive option for doctors in the United States, experts said.
However, this latest finding warns that the newer technique may lead to bleeding problems after the patient leaves the operating room.
"The complication rates after tonsillectomies with diathermy [a 'hot' technique] are higher than bleeding rates with 'cold steel' techniques," said lead researcher Dr. Jan van der Meulen, a senior lecturer in health services research from the Royal College of Surgeons of England and the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
The report appears in the Aug. 21 issue of The Lancet.
"Hot" techniques include diathermy, which uses an electric current to remove tonsils and to control bleeding, and coblation, a variation of electrosurgery, which reduces the chance of heat damage. The "cold" technique, where the tonsils are cut out, uses ice packs or ties to minimize bleeding during the operation, van der Meulen explained.
To find out which method carried a greater risk of postoperative bleeding, van der Meulen's team collected data on postoperative complications from all tonsillectomies done in 334 hospitals in England and Northern Ireland.
The data looked at 12,000 patients who had hot or cold tonsillectomies and included all age groups.
The researchers found bleeding occurred in 3.3 percent of patients within 28 days after surgery, and diathermy increased the rate of bleeding by as much as 6 percent, compared with the "cold" technique.
In addition, they found that adults had higher bleeding rates than children, and bleeding was more likely when junior surgeons did the operation.
The researchers blame the problem on using too much power during diathermy.
"Diathermy should be used more carefully," van der Meulen said. If diathermy is used with the current setting too high, too much surrounding tissue is damaged, which can result in problems days after the surgery.
"During surgery, if you use diathermy at high settings, you stop bleeding very, very well," van der Meulen said. "But you are not aware that you can cause problems later."
Diathermy is used in many surgical procedures, van der Meulen said. "What we find in tonsillectomy might be the case in other procedures as well," he noted.
"This is an example of innovation in surgery where you try to help patients better, but in practice you might do more harm than good," van der Meulen said. "The old-fashioned technique might be better in the end."
However, most doctors in the United States have already made the switch to "hot" surgeries, said Dr. Michael A. Rothschild, chief of pediatric ear, nose and throat surgery at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City.
"These techniques are associated with less bleeding during the operation, but slightly more bleeding after the surgery," he said, adding that he doesn't see this as a significant problem.
And Dr. Glenn C. Isaacson, a professor and chairman of the department of otolaryngology-head and neck surgery at Temple University School of Medicine in Philadelphia, noted the study sheds little new light on the debate over the two surgical approaches.
"Otolaryngologists who care for small children tend to prefer hot techniques as speed and minimal blood loss at the time of surgery are important in this group," Isaacson said. "Ear, nose and throat surgeons who care for adults prefer cold techniques, as speed is less important and late bleeding is a greater concern."
The National Library of Medicine can tell you more about tonsillectomies.
This story may be outdated. We suggest some alternatives.
The content contained in this article is over two years old. As such our recommendation is that you reference the articles below for the latest updates on this topic. This article has been left on our site as a matter of historic record. Please contact us at email@example.com with any questions.