Report Suggests Zika's Effect on Fetus May Be Even Deadlier Than Thought
But some scientists say link is still inconclusive
THURSDAY, Feb. 25, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- Zika virus may harm a fetus to a greater degree than previously suggested, potentially causing a range of life-threatening birth defects, a new report says.
The stillborn baby of a 20-year-old Brazilian woman infected with Zika had almost no brain tissue, which is a birth defect called hydraencephaly, according to the case study.
The fetus also suffered from microcephaly, the most common birth defect thought to be caused by the mosquito-borne virus. Children with this birth defect have underdeveloped heads and brains.
Most troubling, the fetus also showed the first reported birth defect potentially caused by Zika that affected a part of the body other than the central nervous system, according to the report authors.
Dangerous amounts of fluid buildup in the fetus caused swelling and damage to different parts of its body, a condition called hydrops fetalis, said the researchers, from Brazil and Yale University. They reported their findings in the Feb. 25 issue of the journal PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases.
It's not certain that Zika was the cause of these abnormalities, and experts say many questions remain unanswered.
In fact, some medical professionals contend that Brazil and some international health officials prematurely declared a link between Zika and an apparent surge in birth defects.
Among them are 14 Brazilian and American researchers who said in the Feb. 24 Annals of Internal Medicine that the connection between the virus and microcephaly "remains presumptive." So far, the evidence is circumstantial, they wrote.
Others health experts said the evidence against the Zika virus is mounting.
Anecdotal reports of Zika causing birth defects other than microcephaly have surfaced, but "this is the first clearly documented case with an obvious link to Zika infection that has been well-documented in a peer-reviewed journal," Stephen Higgs, director of the Biosecurity Research Institute at Kansas State University, said of the PLOS study.
The case study shows that the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was on the right track when it recommended that any pregnant woman who's been to a Zika-affected region be tested for the virus, said Dr. Veronique Tache, an assistant professor of maternal-fetal medicine at the University of California, Davis.
This was the first time Tache heard of Zika potentially causing such extensive damage to a fetus, but she said she is not surprised by the report.
"It's a devastating finding, but it goes along with what these early onset congenital infections can do to the fetus," Tache said.
Zika's impact on fetal development tracks closely to cytomegalovirus (CMV), another fetal infection that can cause a wide array of birth defects and health problems, Tache said.
Children infected with CMV in the womb can suffer from microcephaly, as well as hearing and vision loss, seizures, and problems with major organs like the liver, lung and heart, according to the CDC.
The effect that measles can have on an unborn baby might serve as another "good model for understanding the full trajectory of fetal Zika infection," said Dr. Amesh Adalja, a senior associate at the UPMC Center for Health Security in Baltimore.
"Congenital infections of all sorts, because they infect a rapidly developing fetus, can have myriad effects on many organ systems as they form," Adalja said. "What is needed is to truly understand the role that Zika may have in causing abnormal development of not just the brain, but all organ systems in gestating fetuses."
Since it first surfaced in Brazil last spring, the Zika virus has spread to more than 32 countries and territories in Latin America and the Caribbean. The World Health Organization estimates there could be up to 4 million cases of Zika in the Americas in the next year.
The Brazilian mother-to-be was having a normal pregnancy during her first trimester, last summer. That changed abruptly during her 18th week of pregnancy, when an ultrasound examination discovered the fetus' weight was well below normal.
The woman did not report any symptoms commonly associated with Zika -- such as a rash, fever or body aches -- prior to or during the early stages of her pregnancy, the report authors said.
But by the 30th week of pregnancy, the fetus showed a range of birth defects. Doctors induced labor at the 32nd week after an ultrasound revealed it had died.
Researchers said they subsequently confirmed the presence of Zika virus in the fetus, apparently the same strain currently spreading throughout Latin America and the Caribbean.
Any pregnant woman who's visited a Zika-infected region should tell her doctor and have her blood tested for the virus, hopefully from two to 12 weeks after potential exposure, Tache said.
After that, the woman should undergo regular ultrasound scans to carefully track fetal development, she said.
"To date, there's no antiviral [drug] that works on the Zika virus, so we're kind of caught between a rock and a hard place," Tache said. "We can make the diagnosis that there's been a Zika infection, but getting infected doesn't necessarily mean that you'll have abnormalities. Not everyone who gets the Zika virus will have an infected fetus."
First discovered in Uganda in 1947, the Zika virus was not thought to pose serious health risks until last year. In fact, approximately 80 percent of people who become infected never experience symptoms.
For more on Zika virus, visit the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
To see the CDC list of sites where Zika virus is active and may pose a threat to pregnant women, click here.