Alcohol May Slow Rheumatoid Arthritis
But results in mice might not apply to humans, scientists say
MONDAY, Dec. 18, 2006 (HealthDay News) -- A copious dose of alcohol reduced the risk that mice would develop rheumatoid arthritis, Swedish researchers report.
That doesn't mean humans should turn to the bottle to stave off the painful joint disease, however.
Asked if he would attempt a similar experiment in humans, lead researcher Dr. Andrzej Tarkowski, professor of rheumatology at Goteborg University said, "I wouldn't dare to do it."
The mice were given a daily regimen of tap water supplemented with 10 percent alcohol. "That would do liver damage in humans," Tarkowski noted.
"There may be some kind of human correlate, but that's not what I'm studying," added Tarkowski, who published the findings in this week's Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Instead, Tarkowski is interested in the mechanism by which alcohol might help prevent rheumatoid arthritis, an autoimmune condition in which the body attacks its own joint tissue.
"We have shown that it goes through the up-regulation [increase] of testosterone," he said. "That down-regulates inflammation, which is part of the arthritic process."
Test tube studies also show that alcohol increases the migration of white blood cells, which take part in the inflammatory process, Tarkowski.
In the experiment, male mice were given injections of collagen to induce rheumatoid arthritis. The researchers noted a significantly lower onset of disease and fewer destructive symptoms in mice who drank water with 10 percent alcohol added in, than in those who drank plain tap water.
Dr Stephen Lindsey, head of rheumatology at the Ochsner Clinic Foundation Hospital in Baton Rouge, La., agreed that the study findings aren't a license to start drinking.
"This paper is germane to male mice," Lindsey said. "That's all we can say at this time." Another reason for caution is that many of the medications used to treat rheumatoid arthritis are also toxic to the liver, as is alcohol, he said. This study also focused on male mice and testosterone, when most rheumatoid arthritis sufferers are female.
Finally, Lindsey said, the study dealt with prevention of arthritis, not its treatment.
The findings do suggest directions for possible trials, he said, perhaps among men with rheumatoid arthritis to see if their condition is affected by alcohol consumption.
However, there is no reason to change the standing recommendations for people with arthritis, he noted.
"The standard advice is to do everything in moderation, other than smoking," Lindsey said. "A couple of cups of coffee a day, one or two drinks a day, but no smoking."
Tarkowski saw some possibility in using acetaldehyde, a breakdown product of alcohol, in prevention of rheumatoid arthritis. However, Lindsey again cautioned that acetaldehyde "would have to be used in relatively small amounts because, in large amounts, it is toxic."
For more on rheumatoid arthritis, head to the Arthritis Foundation.