Half of Men Fail to Check if Vasectomy is Working
Doctors routinely ask that men come back to ensure effectiveness, but many don't, study finds
MONDAY, Dec. 28, 2009 (HealthDay News) -- Nearly half of men who get vasectomies don't return for follow-up tests that make sure the procedure is working, new research suggests.
Those who don't go back, and therefore risk an unwanted pregnancy, are more likely to be smokers, not highly educated and the fathers of four or more children, the study found.
The findings show the need for better communication between doctors and vasectomy patients, especially those at higher risk of not following up, said study co-author Yefim Sheynkin, an associate professor of urology at the State University of New York at Stony Brook.
Overall, vasectomy is a "pretty darned good" form of birth control, said Dr. John K. Amory, an associate professor of medicine at the University of Washington Medical School "It's about 99 percent effective."
In rare cases, a vasectomy fails. In those cases, sperm can make it into semen and impregnate a woman.
To make sure that any remaining sperm has cleared out of the vas deferens tubes, doctors routinely ask patients to provide a semen sample about three months after the vasectomy procedure, Amory said.
Total clearance usually takes 20 to 30 ejaculations, he said, noting sperm can stay alive for weeks.
"We want to see a sperm count of zero after three months," he said. "There are millions and millions of sperm. If only 1 percent of them are alive, that's still a lot."
Amory said about half of men fail to return for the follow-up test, and the new study confirms that number.
The researchers, who report their findings in the December issue of Contraception, examined the medical records of 214 vasectomy patients to see what role sociodemographic factors might play in follow-up.
Forty-six percent didn't get a post-vasectomy semen analysis. Age and marital status made no difference, but men who didn't return were less likely to be college-educated, the researchers found.
Doctors explicitly tell patients to return for a sperm check, but since the message is not getting across, there's talk of other strategies, Sheynkin said. These might include making follow-up appointments at the time of a vasectomy and using home semen analysis tests.
The latter strategy is promising, said Amory. He envisions men buying test kits at the store or online, as women do with pregnancy tests.
"The man could masturbate in a cup at home, take a sample of semen, put in a tester, and it will tell them about their sperm count," he said. Eventually, he said, "I think vasectomy clinics will hand those out to people to use them in three months."
Test kits exist for men to determine if they're sterile, but they're designed to detect high numbers of sperm, not low ones, Amory said.
Learn more about vasectomies from familydoctor.org.